Acrylic Nails vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (2024)

Acrylic Nails vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (1)

Glitterbels . / 19th January 2023

Acrylic nails are made by mixing a liquid (monomer) and powder (polymer) to create a paste, which is then applied to the natural nails. The mixture hardens and forms a durable layer over the natural nails. Acrylic nails are known for their durability and strength, and they can be shaped and filed to create various looks. However, they can also be harsh on natural nails and may cause damage if not applied or maintained correctly.

On the other hand, gel nails are applied using a gel-based polish cured under a UV lamp. The resulting nails are shiny and look natural, and the gel polish is typically more flexible than acrylic. Gel nails are also known for being easy to remove and less likely to cause damage to natural nails. However, they are typically more expensive than acrylic nails and require a UV lamp for curing.

Comparison of Acrylic and Gel Nails

Appearance and durability

Acrylic nails and gel nails both have different appearances and levels of durability.

Appearance

Acrylic nails have a more artificial look than gel nails and are often thicker and more opaque. On the other hand, gel nails have a more natural appearance; they are shiny and have a glossy finish. They look more like natural nails than acrylic nails.

Durability

Acrylic nails are known for their durability and strength. They are resistant to chipping and breaking, making them a popular choice for people who have a busy lifestyle or who engage in activities that put their nails at risk of damage. Gel nails, while durable, aren't as strong as acrylic nails. They are more flexible than acrylic nails and less resistant to chipping or breaking.

In general, acrylic nails are more durable than gel nails, but gel nails have a more natural look. The choice between the two will depend on the individual's needs, preferences and lifestyle.

It's worth mentioning that both types of nails can be prone to cracking or chipping if not appropriately maintained, and both need regular fill-ins to preserve their appearance.

Application process

The application process for acrylic nails and gel nails is different.

Acrylic Nails

Acrylic nails are applied by mixing a liquid (monomer) and powder (polymer) to create a paste, which is then applied to the natural nails. The mixture is then sculpted and shaped over a form or on the natural nails. The nails are then filed and shaped to the desired length and shape. The process can take up to an hour or more, depending on the skill of the nail technician and the desired look.

Gel Nails

Gel nails are applied by painting a gel-based polish over the natural nails. The nails are then cured under a UV lamp. The process typically takes 30 minutes to an hour. Still, it can vary depending on the skill of the nail technician and the desired look.

It's worth mentioning that both types of nails require proper nail preparation, which includes cleaning, buffing and dehydrating the natural nails before application.

In summary, the application process of acrylic nails is more involved and time-consuming than gel nails. Acrylic nails require mixing a liquid and powder, sculpting and shaping, while gel nails require painting and curing under a UV lamp. Both types of nails require proper nail preparation before application.

Maintenance and removal

Acrylic nails and gel nails both require regular maintenance and have different removal processes.

Maintenance

Acrylic nails must be filled in every two to three weeks to maintain their appearance. During a fill-in, the technician will remove the grown-out portion of the natural nails and add a new layer of acrylic to the nails. They are also prone to yellowing or discolouration over time, so regular buffing and cleaning are required to maintain their appearance.

Gel nails must also be filled in every two to three weeks to maintain their appearance. During a fill-in, the technician will remove the grown-out portion of the natural nails and add a new layer of gel to the nails. Gel nails are less prone to yellowing or discolouration than acrylic nails. However, regular cleaning is still required to maintain their appearance.

Removal

Acrylic nails are removed by soaking them in acetone for 15-20 minutes, then filing and buffing off the remaining acrylic. This process can be harsh on the natural nails and may cause damage if not done correctly.

Gel nails are also removed using acetone that is applied to the nails, wrapped in foil, and left on for 10-15 minutes. The gel polish can then be gently buffed off. This process is less harsh on the natural nails than the removal of acrylic nails.

In summary, the maintenance and removal process of acrylic nails is more time-consuming and harsher on natural nails than gel nails. Gel nails are less prone to yellowing or discolouration and less harsh on the natural nails during the removal process than acrylic nails.

Cost

Acrylic and gel nails can vary in cost depending on the location, nail salon and technician. Still, acrylic nails generally tend to be less expensive than gel nails.

Acrylic Nails

Acrylic nails are typically less expensive than gel nails. A complete set of acrylic nails can range from £30 to £60, and a fill-in can range from £20 to £40. The cost may vary based on the nails' design, length and shape and the technician's skill.

Gel Nails

Gel nails are typically more expensive than acrylic nails. A complete set of gel nails can range from £40 to £80, and a fill-in can range from £30 to £50. The cost may vary based on the nails' design, length and shape and the technician's skill.

It's worth mentioning that both types of nails require regular maintenance, and the costs of maintaining them can add up over time. The price of a UV lamp (needed for gel nails) should also be considered.

In summary, acrylic nails tend to be less expensive than gel nails. Still, the cost can vary depending on location, salon, technician, nail art, length and shape of the nails, and the technician's skill. Both types of nails require regular maintenance, and the costs can add up over time.

Pros and Cons of Acrylic Nails

Advantages of Acrylic Nails

They're Durable

One of the biggest benefits of acrylic nails is that they are very durable. They can last up to six weeks without chipping or peeling, which is much longer than natural nails. Additionally, acrylic nails are less likely to break than natural nails, so they can be a good option for people who have weak or brittle nails.

They're Affordable

Another benefit of acrylic nails is that they are relatively affordable. While the initial cost of getting them done may be higher than other types of manicures, they will last much longer, so you won't have to get them done as often. Additionally, there are many different styles and colours of acrylic nails available, so you can find a look that suits your taste and budget.

They're Relatively Low Maintenance

Acrylic nails are also low maintenance. Unlike natural nails, they don't require regular polishing or touch-ups. Additionally, acrylic nails don't require any special care or cleaning products, so they're easy to take care of.

They Look Great

Acrylic nails also look great. They can give your hands a polished and sophisticated look, and there are many different styles and colours to choose from. Whether you want a natural look or something more flashy, you can find an acrylic nail style that suits you.

They're Customisable

Another benefit of acrylic nails is that they are highly customisable. You can choose the shape, size, colour, and style of your nails to create a unique look that reflects your personality.

Disadvantages of Acrylic Nails

They Can Damage Your Nails

One of the biggest disadvantages of acrylic nails is that they can damage your natural nails. Acrylic nails are applied with a strong adhesive, which can cause your natural nails to become weak and brittle. Additionally, the acrylic itself can be harsh on your nails, causing them to become dry and damaged. If you wear acrylic nails regularly, you may notice that your natural nails become yellow and discoloured.

They’re Not Very Natural-Looking

While there are many different types of fake nails on the market, acrylics tend to look the least natural. Acrylics are made from a plastic material, which can give them a bright, artificial appearance. If you’re looking for fake nails that look more natural, you may want to consider options such as gel or silk nails.

Pros and Cons of Gel Nails

Advantages of Gel Nails

Natural Look

Gel nails have a glossy, natural-looking finish that is similar to natural nails. This makes them a great choice for people who want to enhance their nails without a harsh or artificial look.

Easy Removal

Gel nails are easy to remove, they are typically removed using a special gel nail polish remover that is applied to the nails, wrapped in foil, and left on for 10-15 minutes. The gel polish can then be gently buffed off. This process is less harsh on the natural nails than the removal of acrylic nails.

Long-lasting

Gel nails can last up to two to three weeks with proper maintenance. This makes them a great choice for people who want to maintain a polished look for an extended period of time.

No Damage to Natural Nails

Gel nails are less likely to cause damage to natural nails than acrylic nails. They are less harsh on the natural nails during the application and removal process, which can be beneficial for people with weaker nails.

Variety of Colors

Gel nails come in a wide variety of colours and shades. This allows for more creative options in terms of nail design and matching nails with different outfits or occasions.

Disadvantages of a Gel Manicure

UV Lamp Required

Gel nails require a UV lamp for curing, which means an additional cost for equipment and the need for regular UV light exposure.

More Expensive

Gel nails are typically more expensive than acrylic nails. A full set of gel nails can range from £40 to £80, and a fill-in can range from £30 to £50. The cost may vary based on the design, length and shape of the nails, and the skill of the technician.

Not as Strong

While gel nails are durable, they are not as strong as acrylic nails. They are more flexible than acrylic nails and can be less resistant to chipping or breaking.

Sensitivity to UV Light

Some people may be sensitive to UV light and could experience discomfort during the curing process or have an allergic reaction to the UV light.

Need for Regular Maintenance

Like any type of artificial nails, gel nails require regular maintenance, and the costs of maintaining them can add up over time. They also need regular fill-ins to maintain their appearance.

Which is right for you?

When choosing between acrylic and gel nails, there are several considerations to keep in mind.

Lifestyle

Consider your daily activities and how they may affect your nails. If you have a busy lifestyle or engage in activities that put your nails at risk of damage, acrylic nails may be a better choice for you because of their strength and durability.

Natural Nail Health

Think about the health of your natural nails and how they may be affected by the application and removal of artificial nails. Gel nails are less harsh on the natural nails during the application and removal process, which can be beneficial for people with weaker nails.

Budget

Consider your budget when choosing between acrylic and gel nails. Acrylic nails tend to be less expensive than gel nails, but the cost can vary depending on location, salon, technician, design, length and shape of the nails, and the skill of the technician.

Look

Think about the look you want to achieve with your nails. Acrylic nails can be shaped and filed to create a variety of different looks, from natural to more extravagant designs. Gel nails, on the other hand, have a more natural look and come in a wide variety of colours and shades.

Maintenance

Think about the level of maintenance you are willing to do to keep your nails looking good. Both types of nails require regular maintenance, but gel nails are less prone to yellowing or discolouration than acrylic nails and less harsh on the natural nails during the removal process.

Conclusion

In summary, when choosing between gel and acrylic nails, it's important to consider your lifestyle, natural nail health, budget, desired look and level of maintenance. Both types of nails have their pros and cons and the best option depends on the individual's needs, preferences, and budget.

Read More Blogs

Let’s hang out

We love it when you tag us in photos!

Our Instagram
Acrylic Nails vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (2024)

FAQs

Acrylic Nails vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? ›

If durability and dramatic length are key, acrylics are the way to go. They're tougher and can be sculpted into long, elaborate designs. However, if you crave a more natural look and prioritize nail health, then a gel manicure might be better.

What is healthier for nails gel or acrylic? ›

Acrylics tend to be more damaging because they're hard and inflexible, which makes them more likely to catch on surfaces and chip or break. Additionally, acrylic nails are more difficult to remove than gel nails, which means that they may be more likely to damage the natural nails.

What is the healthiest nail option? ›

Choose soak-off gel nails instead of acrylic nails.

This means your own nails are less likely to crack. You'll want to ask for gel nails that soak off rather than ones that must be filed off.

Do gel nails damage your nails? ›

Although gel manicures can be beautiful and long-lasting, they can be tough on nails. Gel manicures can cause nail brittleness, peeling and cracking, and repeated use can increase the risk for skin cancer and premature skin aging on the hands.

Do acrylic nails need UV light? ›

Acrylic nails do not dry under UV light. When the monomer is mixed with the polymer it starts a chemical reaction that causes the mixture to cure and harden. Although the product feels hard after a few minutes, it can take up to 24 hours for the curing process to be complete.

Why do people prefer acrylic over gel? ›

If durability and dramatic length are key, acrylics are the way to go. They're tougher and can be sculpted into long, elaborate designs. However, if you crave a more natural look and prioritize nail health, then a gel manicure might be better.

What are the pros and cons of acrylic vs gel? ›

Gel polish looks like traditional nail polish, but hardens much more and is stronger than a regular manicure. However, they are still more flexible than acrylic, making them a less intimidating option and are generally not as harsh on the nails. Gel is also quicker and easier to remove than acrylic.

What nail service is least damaging? ›

Overall, Dip Powder Manicures are a great way to get a healthy manicure that will protect and strengthen your nails without causing any damage. Just like any nail treatment, you do have to make sure you properly remove it to keep your nails safe and healthy – Don't pick at your manicure!

What type of nails are least damaging? ›

No Damage to Natural Nails

Gel nails are less likely to cause damage to natural nails than acrylic nails. They are less harsh on the natural nails during the application and removal process, which can be beneficial for people with weaker nails.

What type of nails look the most natural? ›

Squoval. "To get this shape, trim nails [with nail clippers] to the length you want in a square shape, and then use a nail file to round the corners," adds King. This shape is flattering on every finger type because it's the most natural, but it looks best on nails that are not longer than the fingertip.

How long is it OK to wear gel nails? ›

The Recommended Lifespan

While gel nails offer longevity compared to regular polish, they do require maintenance and removal. Our nail technicians recommend getting a gel nail complete removal and reapplication every two to three weeks, depending on your nail growth and lifestyle.

What is the new alternative to gel nails? ›

For starters, BIAB is a professional-only soak-off soft-gel “specifically formulated to be used as an overlay on the natural nail,” explains Giorgia. It's gentler than acrylic, but thicker than regular nail polish and gel polish.

Why shouldn't you pick off gel nails? ›

Picking at your gel manicure is really bad for your nails. It not only peels away the polish, but the top layer of your nail too. This damages it, weakening the nails, so they are more prone to rough textures and white patches. It also makes them more susceptible to cracking and breaking.

What is a healthy alternative to fake nails? ›

Gel nail extensions are lighter and healthier for your natural nails. They are also safer because they do not use so many harsh chemicals. They are highly durable and long-lasting. They won't lift and fade quickly.

Can gel nails be healthy? ›

Gel nail polish contains various chemicals, and some may cause adverse effects. Research from 2018 and 2021 found that gel nail polish contains methacrylates and acrylates. These can cause skin irritation, such as hives and contact dermatitis. One common concern with gel manicures is exposure to UV rays.

Which lasts longer acrylic nails or gel nails? ›

Acrylic nails can last you around a week or so. Gel nails or gel extensions last for at least 14-15 days. Since acrylic nails last for a shorter duration of time, they are not durable. Gel nails are more durable than acrylic nails, making them suitable for daily chores or sporty activities.

What are the safest nail extensions? ›

Gel extensions are generally considered the healthier alternative to acrylics—both for you and your nail technician. “Gel extensions are lightweight and look more natural than acrylic nails,” says Nguyen.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jerrold Considine

Last Updated:

Views: 6418

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jerrold Considine

Birthday: 1993-11-03

Address: Suite 447 3463 Marybelle Circles, New Marlin, AL 20765

Phone: +5816749283868

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Air sports, Sand art, Electronics, LARPing, Baseball, Book restoration, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Jerrold Considine, I am a combative, cheerful, encouraging, happy, enthusiastic, funny, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.